Controversial Yorkshire Puddings

Controversial Yorkshire Puddings

Yorkshire puddings are a staple of any great roast dinner, but achieving those perfectly puffed, golden delights can sometimes feel like a culinary gamble. While tradition dictates that the oil must be piping hot before you add the batter, I’ve discovered a controversial technique that works beautifully in the AGA—and perhaps even in a conventional oven (though I haven’t tried it yet!).

AGA cooking always sparks opinions, especially when Yorkshire puddings are involved. If you’re still learning the ovens, our guide to how AGA cookers work is a useful place to start.

Here’s the twist: start cold. Yes, you read that right. Forget heating the oil to the smoking point. Instead, place your muffin tray into the AGA with both the oil and the batter cold, and let the magic happen.

How It Works:

  1. Prepare Your Batter
    Whisk up a traditional Yorkshire pudding batter - 100g Plain Flour, 3 eggs, beaten, 225 ml milk and a pinch of salt.  Leave to rest for 30 mins, if you have the time. 

     

  2. Add Cold Oil to the Tray
    Pour a small amount of vegetable or sunflower oil into each compartment of your 12 hole muffin tray. Keep it cold—no preheating!





  3. Pour Batter Onto Cold Oil
    Ladle the batter directly on top of the oil, divide equally across the tin.





  4. Straight Into the AGA
    Place the tray in the AGA’s roasting oven (or a very hot conventional oven). Bake for about 20 minutes and the Yorkies are well risen and golden brown






The Results

This unconventional method delivers Yorkshire puddings that rise evenly, with a crisp exterior and fluffy center. The gradual heating seems to create a perfect synergy between the oil and the batter, ensuring no stodgy middles or uneven puffing.

Some purists may scoff at skipping the “smoking hot oil” step, but as far as I’m concerned, this technique is foolproof. The AGA’s consistent heat is a game-changer for this approach, although adventurous cooks might want to try it in a conventional oven too.

Perfect Yorkies every time—who could argue with that?

 

And if your cooker is the heart of the kitchen, a pair of chef’s pads or lid covers is a lovely way to protect the lids and add a bit of personality.

 

Back to blog

Controversial Yorkshire Puddings FAQs

Why are these Yorkshire puddings called “controversial”?

Traditional Yorkshire pudding recipes usually insist that the oil must be extremely hot before adding the batter. This method is considered controversial because it starts with both the oil and batter cold, allowing them to heat together in the oven.

Can you make Yorkshire puddings in an AGA?

Traditional Yorkshire pudding recipes usually insist that the oil must be extremely hot before adding the batter. This method is considered controversial because it starts with both the oil and batter cold, allowing them to heat together in the oven.

What ingredients are used in Yorkshire pudding batter?

Traditional Yorkshire pudding batter is made from just a few simple ingredients: eggs, flour and milk. When baked in hot fat, the batter rises and forms the crisp, airy puddings that are often served with roast dinners.

Why do Yorkshire puddings rise in the oven?

Yorkshire puddings rise because the batter contains eggs and liquid that expand rapidly when heated. When the batter hits the hot fat in the oven, steam forms and pushes the batter upward, creating the characteristic puffed shape.